The Todal
2017-02-27 13:23:00 UTC
For those who think you should never bother A&E if your GP is the best
person to see.
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-4260108/Girl-5-died-asthma-attack-GP-refused-her.html
Shanice arrived at the surgery with Ellie-May just after 5pm. According
to the NHS report, Shanice said she arrived at ‘about 5.08pm’.
However, she insisted to this paper it was 5.04pm. Mother and daughter
then waited several minutes while the receptionist dealt with a phone
call and another patient.
The receptionist finally addressed Shanice at 5.18pm, the report notes,
calling through to Dr Rowe to ask if she would see them. According to
the receptionist’s account, the GP then ‘shouted something like “No I’m
not seeing her, she’s late”.’
When the health board investigated, it found Dr Rowe gave incorrect
information, including her claim to be with another patient at the time.
They also found that staff were ‘fearful of questioning’ Dr Rowe due her
‘angry outbursts’.
It concluded the ‘root cause’ of the child’s death was that Dr Rowe
‘refused to see EM [Ellie-May] because she was brought in late’. It also
noted that months earlier a hospital paediatrician had written to Dr
Rowe warning that Ellie-May was ‘at risk of another episode of severe /
life-threatening asthma’.
Despite this, the report said, Dr Rowe ‘did not make any clinical
assessment of EM before refusing to see her’ and failed to give her
mother any ‘safety netting advice’.
The ‘serious concern’ was passed to the GMC but Dr Rowe was allowed to
continue practising with only minor restrictions.
person to see.
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-4260108/Girl-5-died-asthma-attack-GP-refused-her.html
Shanice arrived at the surgery with Ellie-May just after 5pm. According
to the NHS report, Shanice said she arrived at ‘about 5.08pm’.
However, she insisted to this paper it was 5.04pm. Mother and daughter
then waited several minutes while the receptionist dealt with a phone
call and another patient.
The receptionist finally addressed Shanice at 5.18pm, the report notes,
calling through to Dr Rowe to ask if she would see them. According to
the receptionist’s account, the GP then ‘shouted something like “No I’m
not seeing her, she’s late”.’
When the health board investigated, it found Dr Rowe gave incorrect
information, including her claim to be with another patient at the time.
They also found that staff were ‘fearful of questioning’ Dr Rowe due her
‘angry outbursts’.
It concluded the ‘root cause’ of the child’s death was that Dr Rowe
‘refused to see EM [Ellie-May] because she was brought in late’. It also
noted that months earlier a hospital paediatrician had written to Dr
Rowe warning that Ellie-May was ‘at risk of another episode of severe /
life-threatening asthma’.
Despite this, the report said, Dr Rowe ‘did not make any clinical
assessment of EM before refusing to see her’ and failed to give her
mother any ‘safety netting advice’.
The ‘serious concern’ was passed to the GMC but Dr Rowe was allowed to
continue practising with only minor restrictions.